Ivan Smirnov, Senior Consultant
WebSphere MQ File Transfer Edition (known simply as MQ FTE) is a robust managed file transfer solution built on WebSphere MQ transport backbone. Product page is here: http://www-01.ibm.com/software/integration/wmq/filetransfer/index.html
This product is a recent addition to the storied and extremely stable WebSphere MQ – it came out after MQ version 7. I was excited to hear about its release because it creates new possibilities in file transfer that FTP, SCP and the like never delivered – like reliability and tolerance of transient network failures. Immediately a question arose: how can we take advantage of these new capabilities in IBM’s middleware. What is the best way to integrate IBM’s premier integration platform, WebSphere ESB (and by extension, WebSphere Process Server) with MQ FTE?
Integration between WESB and MQ FTE will occur on 2 ESB boundaries: module exports that receive files from MQ FTE and module imports that send files to a remote destination via MQ FTE. I argue that the simplest integration approach is also often the best.
On the SCA export (send files via MQ FTE) side, we will configure MQ FTE file transfer using the tool’s native interface (command line or GUI). We then will use Flat File adapter in outbound mode to create a file on local file system where it will be picked up by MQ FTE. Protection from incomplete file pickup is provided by using staging directory, which is built into Flat File adapter.
The following alternatives are possible:
1) Construct the whole MQ FTE messages on the fly in WESB (for instance, by engineering an MQ FTE import binding)
2) Put file on file system the same way, using Flat File adapter, but initiate transfer by putting a request message on MQ FTE agent queue.
The first alternative approach requires duplicating a lot of code that is already in MQ FTE while providing minimal savings in terms of disk I/O. It is not a worthy alternative.
The second alternative approach is close to the original design. However, there is no need to predefine file transfer – this will be done by sending an XML message to administrative queue of MQ FTE. Its benefit is zero administration effort, but it requires some upfront custom development.
On the SCA import (receive from MQ FTE) side, we can configure MQ FTE to transfer files to a local WESB file system. Files will be picked up by Flat File Adapter in inbound mode. MQ FTE has built in protection against picking up incomplete files.
As an alternative, it is certainly possible to receive MQ messages in WESB instead of letting MQ FTE create files on file system. This alternate solution will require complex code largely duplicating existing MQ FTE functionality to extract file payload from MQ messages and handle file-level acknowledgement and auditing. The only upside would be avoiding disk I/O by skipping writing file to file system by MQ FTE and reading it in by Flat File adapter. There is not much value in this, since at such high volume WESB will reach capacity much sooner then disk I/O becomes a bottleneck. This alternate solution is all cost and no benefit.
Conclusion: when integrating MQ FTE and WPS (WESB), simplest solution is very reasonable and will work best in many situations.
Ivan Smirnov is a Senior Consultant at Prolifics with extensive hands-on experience with the WebSphere family of products (including WebSphere Application Server and Process Server, WebSphere Studio/Rational and WebSphere MQ), Tivoli security offerings (including Tivoli Identity Manager and Tivoli Access Manager for e-business), DB2, XML and Web Services. With strong technical skills both in development and administration, as well as deep troubleshooting skills, Ivan handles aspects of implementation installation, configuration, securing and tuning/troubleshooting to development and architecture within a J2EE environment. He also possesses key Application Server migration skills and has helped several customers’ transition to the WebSphere platform from other J2EE platforms.
Posts
